Starfield is great imo. But I wasn’t left amazed and empty after finishing the main story like TOTK and AC6. Haven’t played BG3 because I don’t think it’s my style but I’ve seen people say it’s better than Elden Ring (my fav game of all time). I’ll probably play Starfield for the next 2-3 years but it’s not up there with these guys
As soon as I saw it I assumed BG3 being soo good it is offsetting all 3 games. While Starfield isn’t as bad as Redfall or Gollum, it isn’t that far off. SF was hyped and is just a reskinned FO/Skyrim with 1 per minute loading screens.
I know I’ll get downvoted for this but does anyone else feel duped by this current generation of consoles? Everything I’ve seen could easily be done on XB1 or PS4 and not have any downgrade in graphical quality. 3 years in and I’m still waiting for those amazing next gen games
Starfield fan boys keeps telling me bg3 will be forgotten about in a month 😂😂 I’m no hater but I highly doubt starfield will reach the play count bg3 is hitting
I wonder if starfield is even going to get nominated for any game awards, realistically no, but I think it’ll get nominated if no other good game gets released
I can understand Starfield (No Todd, my RTX 3070 is fine, I don’t upgrade my Rig yet)
But seriously, BG3? I admit it has some bugs and needs some optimizations, but it has a massive amount of interations and ways to do things. It’s normal for a title like this to be a little bit “broken” at the launch
I still remember people defending Gollum when it launched, and to this day I’m amazed there’s people that liked the At Home Gollum, when Shadow of Mordor did him and the orcs way better almost a decade ago.
3 games that I’ve heard mixed/bad things about and one game I’ve heard nothing but praise of
Man I completely forgot about Redfall. Shit fell off the face of the planet.
So starfield and Baldur’s gate, two great games, are balancing out Redfall and Gollum, two terrible games?
Ac6 would have been a better pick imo
Zelda and BG3
To beat a dead horse…
Starfield’s alright. It’s not terrible by any means, but it’s certainly not at the calibre of BG3.
I would have used pikmin 4 instead of starfield. Pikmin is generally more favorably viewed.
It’s even got a higher metacritic score. And a far higher user review score.
Its one of the only games that has a higher user rating than critic rating. So people really love it
Hogwarts was also this year and also really well recieved
[deleted]
A great game, 2 shit games, and a mid-good game?
Not sure I’d put Starfield and BG3 on the same level.
Starfield is ranked more with FF16 if anything, more circlejerk for BG3 to be paired with TOTK
Redfall it’s bad no argument here but it’s a masterpiece compared to gollum https://youtu.be/adbsYyb0s6A?si=NXzZkGPcBW7vkQ42
I assume shit games vs good games?
Also real talk…did anyone think Redfall was gonna be good? It looked dumb as hell since forever to me
Starfield is great imo. But I wasn’t left amazed and empty after finishing the main story like TOTK and AC6. Haven’t played BG3 because I don’t think it’s my style but I’ve seen people say it’s better than Elden Ring (my fav game of all time). I’ll probably play Starfield for the next 2-3 years but it’s not up there with these guys
Seriously top right heavy.
1 almost perfect game, 1 mediocre game and 2 absolute terrible games. Yep balance alright.
Why is BG3 in this picture?
Usually the game below Baldurs gate for this meme is supposed to another good game, not a trash one.
If baldurs gate is a 10 Starfield is a 5 so no.
[removed]
would be, if the other half were actually good. (you know what I mean)
The other two games shouldn’t even be near BG3 and Starfield.
all 3 balanced with baldurs gate 3
as it should be
As soon as I saw it I assumed BG3 being soo good it is offsetting all 3 games. While Starfield isn’t as bad as Redfall or Gollum, it isn’t that far off. SF was hyped and is just a reskinned FO/Skyrim with 1 per minute loading screens.
gollum goty 🥇
Forspoken was a 2023 ‘AAA’ game, and it was terrible.
Yes you are right, Baldur’s Gate balances out the other three.
Inverted shopping cart wheels, bg3 the only real good one lol
I know I’ll get downvoted for this but does anyone else feel duped by this current generation of consoles? Everything I’ve seen could easily be done on XB1 or PS4 and not have any downgrade in graphical quality. 3 years in and I’m still waiting for those amazing next gen games
Starfield fan boys keeps telling me bg3 will be forgotten about in a month 😂😂 I’m no hater but I highly doubt starfield will reach the play count bg3 is hitting
I can only see 1 good game in there.
Man, this comment section is lighting up with some high quality salt
Redfall: Bad | BG3: Good
Gollum: Bad | Starfield: Bad
Where’s the balance?
I wonder if starfield is even going to get nominated for any game awards, realistically no, but I think it’ll get nominated if no other good game gets released
I can understand Redfall
I can understand Gollum
I can understand Starfield (No Todd, my RTX 3070 is fine, I don’t upgrade my Rig yet)
But seriously, BG3? I admit it has some bugs and needs some optimizations, but it has a massive amount of interations and ways to do things. It’s normal for a title like this to be a little bit “broken” at the launch
Is it bad I think all 4 are shit
I still remember people defending Gollum when it launched, and to this day I’m amazed there’s people that liked the At Home Gollum, when Shadow of Mordor did him and the orcs way better almost a decade ago.
2 catastrophic games, 1 mediocre game and masterpiece BG3.
Where is the balance?
Starfield > BG3
Stay mad turn based lovers
Baldur’s Gate 3 and Starfield are absolutely not of the same caliber of quality aside from being released within proximity
Lmao, two awful games, a really good one and a mediocre one
Bg 3 is so good it carrys 3 games
Only one good game on this list.
The four horsemen of the crapocolypse.